What’s Really Behind Perfectionism? Unpacking the Fear, Shame, and Control

Photo by Perfect Snacks on Unsplash

Perfectionism doesn’t just mean working hard or aiming for high goals. Striving for excellence can be motivating and rewarding; it comes from a place of curiosity, purpose, and joy. On the other hand, perfectionism is fueled by a fear of failure and the belief that anything less than perfect is unacceptable.

Perfectionism says, “If I make a mistake, I’m a failure.” It’s rigid, unforgiving, and anxiety-inducing. The goal isn’t about doing your best. Instead, you’re avoiding criticism, judgment, or shame at all costs. Here’s how fear, shame, and control are at the root of perfectionism and what you can do about it.

Fear: “What If I’m Not Good Enough?”

At the core of perfectionism lies fear, usually fueled by the suspicion that we’re not enough. Perfectionistic people might worry that if they let their guard down, even a little, they’ll be exposed as incompetent, unworthy, or flawed. Early experiences often shape this fear. When children are only praised for their achievements or criticized harshly for their mistakes, they may grow up to be perfectionists.

Over time, the brain learns to equate performance with safety. The thought process is, “If I get everything right, I won’t be rejected. I’ll stay safe.” So the perfectionist sets impossible standards and works tirelessly to meet them, trying to outrun fear by doing more and doing it flawlessly. Of course, the bar is always moving. Even when something goes well, there’s the voice that says, “You could’ve done better.” That voice is fear cloaked in the language of self-improvement.

Shame: “I Am My Mistakes.”

Perfectionism is often linked to the deep, painful feeling that we are fundamentally flawed. For perfectionists, mistakes aren’t just errors; they feel like personal failures. A typo in an email, a missed deadline, or a less-than-stellar presentation aren’t just things that happened. Instead, they’re evidence that you should be ashamed.

This internalized shame can stem from environments where love or approval was conditional. If a child learns that being accepted depends on success, politeness, or appearance, they may come to believe that their worth is something to be earned rather than something inherent. So they strive for perfection not out of pride, but to keep that shame at bay.

The problem is that perfectionism never actually heals shame; it just temporarily covers it up. And when perfection inevitably fails (because no one is perfect), the shame comes flooding back even stronger.

Control: “If I Can Manage Everything, I Won’t Get Hurt.”

Perfectionism is also about control. When we feel powerless in some areas of our lives, we may overcompensate by trying to control what we can. This might mean keeping a tight rein on our performance, appearance, routines, or the perception others have of us. It’s a way to create the illusion of safety.

Your brain might say, “If I can control all the details, nothing will go wrong. If I can manage every outcome, no one will criticize me. If I can present a flawless version of myself, I won’t be vulnerable.”

This need for control can lead to anxiety, rigidity, and burnout. Relationships suffer, spontaneity disappears, and self-compassion becomes impossible. Over time, the quest for control can make life feel smaller and more exhausting.

Healing Perfectionism

Addressing perfectionism isn’t about “lowering your standards” or trying to be more laid-back. It’s about meeting these emotions that drive the perfectionistic patterns. That often means building up your tolerance for vulnerability. Being human involves mistakes, messiness, and uncertainty.

This work isn’t always easy to do on your own. Contact me today to talk about therapeutic approaches for anxiety and perfectionism that can help. Together, we can explore the roots of your perfectionism, help you develop more compassionate self-talk, and shift your focus from proving your worth to accepting it.