Why You Might Feel Regret After a Breakup—Even If It Was the Right Choice

Photo by mariyan rajesh on Unsplash

Breakups are rarely simple. Even when you know in your heart that ending a relationship was the right choice, you might still find yourself wrestling with regret, second-guessing your decision, and wondering what might have been. This emotional whiplash can be confusing and even distressing.

If the relationship wasn’t working, it means you weren’t happy, your needs weren’t being met, or you tried and tried and still felt stuck. So why are you feeling so unsure now? The truth is, regret after a breakup is incredibly common, even when the breakup was necessary. And understanding why this happens can help you move through the pain with more clarity and self-compassion.

Grieving What Was Good

No relationship is all bad. Even in unhealthy or incompatible relationships, there are often tender moments like shared laughter, emotional intimacy, or small daily rituals that felt comforting. When the relationship ends, it’s natural to grieve the loss of those good parts. This grieving process can easily be mistaken for regret.

You might find yourself missing your ex, replaying the positive memories, and questioning whether leaving was the right thing to do. But missing someone doesn’t automatically mean you made the wrong choice. It just means you experienced something real, even if it wasn’t sustainable long-term.

The Power of Attachment

Emotional bonds don’t dissolve the moment a relationship ends. Even when you’re convinced that your breakup was necessary, your emotional brain might still crave connection with your ex. This is especially true if your attachment system is activated, meaning you feel anxious, lonely, or vulnerable after the breakup. This longing can lead to distorted memories.

You might start to idealize your ex or minimize the issues you had together. This can also look like focusing more on the emotional safety of what’s familiar than on the reality of why the relationship didn’t work. This tug-of-war between emotional attachment and rational awareness can fuel your regret.

The “What If” Spiral

Breakups can stir up a lot of uncertainty. Even if you made a well-thought-out decision, it’s easy to fall into the trap of “what if” thinking: What if I’d tried harder? What if things would’ve gotten better? What if I never find someone else?

These thoughts can be especially loud during periods of loneliness or low self-esteem. But most of these thoughts are rooted in fear, not truth. They’re your mind’s way of trying to regain control after a destabilizing experience.

Cultural Pressures

We live in a culture that often romanticizes relationships and stigmatizes breakups, especially if a relationship seemed “good on paper.” You may receive implicit (or explicit) messages that say you’re supposed to fight for love, that ending things is giving up, or that relationships are supposed to last forever if they’re “meant to be.”

You might feel pressure to explain or justify your decision to others—or even to yourself. Other people’s surprise or disapproval of the breakup can intensify your regret. You might start wondering if you’re being too picky or too emotional. But no one else lives inside your experience.

Loss of Identity

When a relationship ends, you’re not just losing a partner; you might also feel like you’re losing a version of your future or a part of yourself. The absence of that imagined life can leave you feeling unmoored and full of doubt.

Regret, in this case, may not be about the relationship itself but about the dreams that are no longer possible. It’s okay to grieve those dreams while still honoring that the breakup was right for you.

Talking It Through

If you’ve recently gone through a breakup and are struggling to come to terms with it, therapy can help. Reach out today to talk about my therapeutic approach to breakup recovery. Together, we can collaborate on developing your sense of identity and trust in yourself again.